People do not want to create content for your brand
“Why would customers want to create content for our brand?” is a question we commonly come across at FreshNetworks. The truthful answer is often “They don’t”. In fact, the question is the wrong one altogether.
Customers don’t want to create content for your brand and we see this with many unsuccessful uses of social media by brands. But customers will create content, and they will do it in a way that is really beneficial for you and your brand, but they are not necessarily doing it to help you.
Understanding motivation for doing anything is important, and this is especially true of social media. You may want consumers to show you lots of photos of exactly how they pack their children’s lunchboxes so that you can better design what you sell to them. Or you may want them to comment on and Like your posts on your Facebook page so that they and their friends will be kept up to date with what your brand is doing. But their motivation for doing this will rarely (if ever) be to help your brand. They are likely to do it for other reasons, and it is these that you need to uncover, before you plan any tactic or campaign, if it is really going to work.
There are many reasons people will choose to engage with you online, and many reasons that they will help you to achieve the aims that you have with your use of social media. The important step is to explore first of all who it is you want to engage in social media, and then to answer to simple (well actually not so simple) questions:
- How engaged are they with us right now
- What do they want from us
Probably exploring current relationships and motivations will let you understand what kind of engagement you can have with people in social media. This is not a one-way relationship; you can’t ask them to do something for you and then expect them to do it. You have to ask them to do something because they want to, something where it is clear what’s in it for them.
It may be that your target audience is looking for advice on how to pack the healthiest lunch for their children, or that they are looking for new ideas of what to feed them. Understanding this helps you to curate an environment in social media where they will be happy to do what you want (send you a photo of the lunchbox so you can better design what you are selling to them) but also provide them with what they want. You can provide experts on nutrition who will compare before-and-after shots of lunchboxes, or you could get mums to share their favourite lunchbox recipes. In both these cases the photos are gathered, just as you need for you brand, but not because you ask for them. Rather, because you engage with people online and they benefit too.
People do not always want to create content for your brand. They do, however, have many other needs that will lead to the same outcome for you. Proper time spent planning and investigating who you are looking to engage and what their motivation is is time well spent. It will help you to understand what both parties will get out of any engagement, and help to ensure that your campaign is not one of the many examples of social media where people really don’t want to engage with you.
The photo in this post is from the great Things real people don’t say about advertising
For social media agency support get in touch or follow us on Twitter.
Eric SIegmann:
Good message Matt. One approach I take with clients is helping them understand the process of branding UGC. Recognizing that it is difficult to get people to engage ‘for’ a brand or within the specific context setup by brand management, a company can benefit greatly by creating an open space where folks do chose to engage and generate content. Then, through dialog and engagement, execute a process to brand that space and the content/engagement within it.
As you’ve mentioned, investigating the ‘who’ is the best first step.
27 February 2011, 5:16 pmjames:
That’s right… Consumers are a very greedy bunch of people.
They will only contribute content to a brand, like you say, unless there is something in it for them.
If you want to use the trendy term, gamification, it requires reward.
28 February 2011, 9:41 amCharlotte:
I’d agree with that, this is why we do A/B and user experience testing.
The kind of consumers you may be able to get hold of (in my experience) are:
> Compers – Those who will do anything for a competition or freebie
> Self-promoters – May promote your content in the hope you promote their book for parents, fishing line business, cat and dog show (or something else).
> People who genuinely like your content – Depends what your selling but these tend to be rare. People DO create content for brands like ASOS because they like it and it adds to their projected self-image (people are self-branding without realising it these days) but even ASOS still promotes with competitions (bribes).
Great post Matt
28 February 2011, 11:14 amSimon Sanders:
See also last year’s “An Open Letter To All of Advertising & Marketing” from “Brian” written about, for example, here >>
28 February 2011, 1:50 pmhttp://www.psfk.com/2010/08/an-open-letter-to-all-of-advertising-and-marketing.html
links for 2011-03-01 » Wha'Happened?:
[...] People do not want to create content for your brand | Social media agency London | FreshNetworks blo… (tags: engagement socialmedia community brands) [...]
1 March 2011, 10:03 amThis week on found on the internet! Enjoy :) « Found on the internet:
[...] People Do Not Want to Create Content for Your Brand: “There are many reasons people will choose to engage with you online, and many reasons that they will help you to achieve the aims that you have with your use of social media. The important step is to explore first of all who it is you want to engage in social media, and then to answer to simple (well actually not so simple) questions.” [...]
5 March 2011, 12:37 amLinks for March 6 2011 | Eric D. Brown:
[...] change an entire company, be smart. Start with focused, achievable goals and programs. Think small.People do not want to create content for your brand by Matt Rhodes on FreshNetworks blogPeople do not always want to create content for your brand. They do, however, have many other needs [...]
6 March 2011, 3:23 pmPeter:
Great Post Matt
A simple shift in focus is all that is needed to really harness the power of social media for brands.
8 March 2011, 10:00 amBut really: Why do people participate in co-creation projects??? | eYeka Co-creation Blog:
[...] for the others self-fulfilment is the most important driver in co-creation project participation. Not every consumer wants to talk with brands, but those who do should be taken care of! Challenging them to come up with creative ideas for real [...]
14 March 2011, 10:26 am